OSS vs Cloud Anomaly Detection

Elementary OSS and Elementary Cloud Platform both offer data anomaly detection. However, there are significant differences in implementation.

There are two types of anomaly detection tests:

Pipeline health monitors - Monitor the pipeline runs, ensuring timely and complete data ingestion and transformation. These monitors monitor metadata to detect volume and freshness issues.
Data quality metrics tests - Run as part of the pipeline, collect metrics by querying the data itself. These include various data quality metrics such as nullness, cardinality, average, length, etc.

Here is a comparison between the implementation of these tests in Elementary Cloud and OSS:

Pipeline Health Monitors - Freshness and Volume

	OSS	Cloud
Implementation	dbt tests	Elementary Cloud monitors
Tests execution	Run in dbt	Run in Cloud
Coverage	Manually added in code	Automated, out-of-the-box full coverage
Configuration	Manual, many parameters required for accuracy	No configuration, automated ML models
Detection mechanism	Z-score, statistical	ML anomaly detection, various models
What is monitored?	Data	Metadata (query history, information schema)
Time to detection	Only when dbt runs	As soon as the problem happens, including sources
Cost	DWH compute	No cost, only metadata is leveraged

	OSS	Cloud
Implementation	dbt tests	Metrics collection in dbt, Elementary Cloud monitors
Tests execution	Run in dbt	Metrics collection in dbt, detection in Cloud
Coverage	Manually added in code	Opt-in, can be added in bulk in Cloud
Configuration	Manual, many parameters required for accuracy	Automated ML models
Detection mechanism	Z-score, statistical	ML anomaly detection, various models
What is monitored?	Data	Data